Product vs Partner Selection

Product vs Partner Selection

28

Jan

Product vs Partner Selection

ERP Selection vs. Implementation: Why They Deserve Separate Decisions

When organizations begin their ERP journey, the natural instinct is to treat software selection and implementation as a single decision. Many assume that choosing the software automatically determines who should implement it. In reality, separating these two decisions can lead to a smoother rollout, better alignment with business goals, and greater long-term value.

1. The Software Decision Is About Fit — The Implementation Decision Is About Execution

Selecting an ERP system is fundamentally about functional and strategic fit:

  • Does it align with your company’s processes?
  • Does it support your industry requirements?
  • Will it scale with your organization’s growth?

Choosing an implementation partner, on the other hand, is about execution and enablement:

  • Can they translate your requirements into a working solution?
  • Do they have the right project management and change management practices?
  • Will they support you effectively after go-live?

Even the most capable ERP software can fail if it’s implemented by a team that doesn’t understand your business model, internal culture, or data environment.

2. Vendors and Partners Have Different Incentives

ERP software publishers (like Sage Intacct, NetSuite, Acumatica, Zoho, or QuickBooks Enterprise) are primarily focused on product adoption and license sales.
Implementation providers — typically consulting firms, value-added resellers (VARs), or system integrators — focus on service delivery, configuration, and user success.

When both roles are treated as one decision, organizations often lose the ability to independently evaluate:

  • How pricing is structured between licenses and services
  • Whether the recommended implementation approach is genuinely right for them
  • Which party is accountable for long-term performance and support

Separating these decisions helps ensure that both the software and the service team are chosen based on merit, fit, and transparency, not on convenience or sales alignment.

3. Independence Prevents “One-Size-Fits-All” Implementations

Many ERP resellers specialize in one product line and use template-based implementations designed for speed and margin efficiency.
While that approach can work for smaller or simpler organizations, it often limits flexibility — especially if your company has unique workflows or reporting needs.

By evaluating the ERP first and then shortlisting independent implementation partners, you maintain the freedom to:

  • Customize your implementation plan
  • Select a team with relevant industry experience
  • Avoid unnecessary modules or add-ons that inflate costs

This approach ensures the solution is tailored to your business, not the other way around.

4. It Enables Clearer Accountability and Governance

When software and implementation are purchased together, accountability can blur.
If issues arise — for example, poor data migration, performance problems, or missed deadlines — it’s common for each party to point to the other.

By selecting the ERP and implementation provider separately, you can:

  • Negotiate clear, independent contracts
  • Define measurable deliverables for both the vendor and the implementer
  • Ensure your project governance remains transparent

This structure creates a checks-and-balances dynamic that reduces project risk and improves overall outcomes.

5. It Opens the Door to Competitive Proposals and Innovation

Separating the decisions allows you to invite multiple implementation partners to propose how they would deliver your chosen ERP system.
That competition often leads to:

  • More accurate cost estimates
  • Better resource allocation
  • Creative deployment approaches that fit your timeline and culture

Independent selection processes encourage providers to earn your business based on their methods, experience, and client track record — not just their sales relationship with the software vendor.

Final Thought

Selecting an ERP system and selecting an implementation partner are two sides of the same journey — but they require different evaluation criteria and skill sets.
By treating them as separate, sequential decisions, organizations gain control, clarity, and confidence. You end up not only with the right ERP solution, but also with a partner who knows how to make it work for your unique business.

At VettedERP.com, this separation is built into our process.
We help companies identify both the best-fit ERP systems and a selection of qualified, vetted implementation partners — so every decision is made with expertise, transparency, and confidence.

🟦 Get a List of Proven ERP Implementation Partners

Looking for implementation partners with a track record of successful ERP projects?
We can connect you with firms that have been vetted for experience, client satisfaction, and industry specialization — all matched to your specific ERP platform and business needs.

👉 Request a list of proven ERP implementation partners